Ymateb i gyhoeddi’r Achos Busnes a’r modelu economaidd ar gyfer y Cynllun Ffermio Cynaliadwy – Dydd Mercher 1 Hydref 2025

Tach 13, 2026 | Datganiadau barn

[Yn Saesneg unig]

For immediate release

“We want the Sustainable Farming Scheme (SFS) to boost nature-friendly farming in Wales to help farmers restore nature and adapt to the impacts of climate change. The Sustainable Farming Scheme (SFS) Business Case published today supports what Wales Environment Link (WEL) has long been pointing – the scheme’s Universal layer alone will not provide sufficient benefit to nature, Welsh citizens nor the public purse. The Business Case states that the scheme’s Optional and Collaborative layers deliver far better returns on the Welsh Government’s investment.

The conclusions are clear – if the SFS is to deliver its goals, Welsh Ministers will need to commit sufficient budget to the Optional and Collaborative layers and provide high-quality, accessible farm advice and guidance to help farmers take up these actions. And it should also mean an end to payments that just patch or prolong up the problems that unsustainable, and particularly intensive farming has created. Truly sustainable farm practices and systems work in harmony with the natural productive capacity of the land; they regenerate, rather than damage our soils, water and wildlife. 

WEL also notes that the economic impact assessment only paints part of the picture – what we’ve been presented with isn’t a full assessment of the SFS. The impact assessment overlooks the farm productivity gains that can take time to materialise, such as improvements to soil health. And the assessment does not consider those upper layers which offer the real support for the nature-friendly farming practices that help make farming more resilient in the face of climate change, which along with biodiversity decline are recognised as the biggest threats to domestic food production. Livestock populations are  already lower than in 2019, the baseline year used for the modelling. For these reasons, we believe the modelling considerably overestimates the possible impact of the SFS. 

The Welsh Government’s ‘SFS payment ready reckoner’ provides a more accurate guide as to what the SFS means for farm business, and we’d encourage farmers to use this tool before worrying about modelled estimates.

The Senedd was the first in the world to declare a nature emergency and has promised to meet global targets for protecting wildlife and habitats by 2030 – just five years away. To get there, big changes are needed, and the new SFS is the main tool to make it happen.”

If you’d like to seek further comment or interviews with WEL / our members, email liz@waleslink.org