As communities across Wales continue to recover from our latest devastating flooding incident caused by Storm Bert, and brace for the incoming Storm Darragh, politicians announced important decisions on how Welsh land is managed. Decisions that will strongly affect our country’s ability to absorb the impacts of our changing climate.
The Welsh Government’s Sustainable Farming Scheme has been in development since 2016, and is necessary because leaving the EU also meant we’d be leaving the Common Agricultural Policy, the EU-wide support scheme for farmers. The Scheme – commonly known as the ‘SFS’ – has been undergoing a re-design for the past 6 months. This was initiated by the Cabinet Secretary following a public consultation and after farmers highlighted concerns about adjusting to the scheme, with the requirement for 10% of their land to hold trees amongst the reasons they were protesting at the beginning of this year.
What was the re-design decision?
On Monday 25th November, Cabinet Secretary for Climate Change and Rural Affairs, Huw Irranca-Davies set out the changes. In short, the Universal Actions have been streamlined, although they retain actions for soils, hedgerows, habitats, and animal health. The ‘10% of land managed for habitat’ rule remains, but the 10% tree cover rule has been dropped. Instead, farms must create a ‘tree planting and hedgerow plan’ by 2030, to achieve a scheme-level tree target that is yet to be set.
The scheme-wide target – which will also rely on the upper tiers, known as the ‘collaborative layer’ and ‘optional layer’, to deliver results – and the promised planned ‘governance mechanism’ on the target will be crucial, and WEL will continue to engage in the process. However, we cannot pretend that this isn’t a disappointment, and it certainly feels like a step back from progress, after initially strong nature proposals.
What does WEL think of the SFS now?
The universal tier has been significantly diminished from a climate and nature perspective. It’s also arguably a response to a broad misunderstanding, with people presuming it to be 10% of the farm planted with trees regardless of existing tree cover; when in reality, the average Welsh farm already has around 6% tree cover, so most would only need to increase this by around 4%. Given the extent of concern expressed and risks to the wider Scheme’s development and take-up, we appreciate the difficult position the Welsh Government has been put in. It is encouraging that there are still elements of the universal layer that have the potential to be progressive and sustainable, provided they are implemented effectively, and use public money to support farmers to deliver genuine benefits for nature and society.
Having said that, it does appear the Universal Actions are more about slowing and halting the loss of nature than restoring it, so we are not confident that they will contribute much to Wales’ commitments on nature targets, made under COP 15’s Global Biodiversity Framework. The decision to do away with the 10% trees target now also brings into question how Wales will meet its ambitious tree-planting targets, including planting 43,000 hectares by 2030. Any path to achieving these targets must include working with farmers, given that 90% of Wales is farmland. As of July 2024, we had only reached 12% of that target. We are in a nature crisis and we cannot keep falling back to the status quo.
We do welcome the retention of the 10% habitat rule, which we consider the bare minimum required to start tackling the nature emergency in Wales. WEL sees no conflict between sustainable food production and this requirement as defined in the revised Scheme Outline. It’s therefore very alarming that there have been some suggestions to scrap this farm-scale target as well, and replace it with a scheme-wide target. Whilst Welsh Government seems committed to it, we must stress its importance, and the Scheme risks being worth little more than the previous Schemes under the Common Agricultural Policy without it. It’s vital the Universal Layer retains the 10% habitats rule for all farms entering the Scheme to ensure all parts of Wales can support a diversity of wildlife and to provide the foundation for nature’s recovery through the higher tiers of the Scheme.
Despite a nature and climate emergency being declared, nature continues to be the ‘poor cousin’ when it comes to policy decisions. We hope this doesn’t also become the case for the SFS. The scheme must reflect the very basic notion that we need nature and that our well-being depends on it. The Welsh Government started off extremely well with its ambitions for this Scheme, and we urge them not to water it down any further; they have listened and they have made it as easy as they can for farmers to use, without entirely removing nature commitments.
Too often, nature is placed in opposition to food production when this couldn’t be further from the truth. The advice from the UK Government’s 2021 Food Security Report clearly highlights the importance of nature for our ability to produce food. The briefing summary states that climate change, climate variability and biodiversity loss all threaten the long-term security of global food production. The report concluded that climate change and biodiversity loss were among the biggest medium to long term risks to UK domestic food production, alongside other factors like soil degradation and water quality. The report also noted that the overexploitation of natural capital resources, such as fish stocks and water, were a threat to global food security.” So it is a false argument to separate nature from food production; one needs the other to survive, they are not in competition, they are essential to each other. Nature is the foundation of our way of life, and we take it for granted at our peril.
Why trees matter
To get the most for trees, it’s vital we end up with the right trees in the right places, and we are glad a duty to make a plan will keep these on the agenda. Storm Bert’s flooding was a timely reminder of why trees are so important, not just for nature, but for the many other benefits they provide.
As the Woodland Trust sets out, trees prevent flooding by:
- Their roots: tree root systems ensure water can go deeper into the soil, meaning less surface run off and more water can be stored in the earth. Water can be absorbed this way 60 times higher on fields with tree belts than tree-less farmland, and of course, actually used by the tree thus reducing pressure on drainage systems. It also prevents soil erosion, stopping it running off away from the farm to where it shouldn’t be.
- Urban trees: trees in cities and towns are just as important, compensating for the increased amount of paving, concrete and tarmac. Surfaces that water can’t penetrate just lead to more run-off, building to flooding. It’s also why it’s crucial that people’s gardens aren’t all converted to patios and paving; the water has to go somewhere, and if it can’t be absorbed into grass or other forms of natural ground cover, it will inevitably flood people’s homes instead.
- Canopy cover: the rain hits the canopy of leaves, branches and trunks before it gets to the ground; this intercepting of rainfall spreads its effects over a longer time period, which is even more beneficial as climate change increases quick and dense rain, causing flash flooding that is even harder to prevent or manage for.
- Acting as dams: along riverbanks and floodplains, trees, shrubs and deadwood act as dams slowing down the flow of water and holding back some of the overspill on the banks.
Trees are hugely beneficial for so many reasons; one study found that tree shelter belts can reduce magnitudes of flood peaks by 40%. And that’s just for when it’s raining; trees even help with producing high quality nutritious food, through grazing of their foliage and preventing soil erosion at field edges, they ensure that arable land remains fertile and productive. Trees are good for farms, but farmers who haven’t been involved in regenerative farming practices and are worried about the changes they’ll have to make, need the right support and advice. Although the changes have said they won’t ‘require’ expert advice, we urge for this to be made very available to them and to ensure all are supported into different ways of managing areas of their land.
Working with nature and not against it
Nature-friendly farmers show that farming with nature is good for business – as set out in the Nature Friendly Farming Network’s ‘Nature Means Business’ report – profitable farms put nature front and centre. As they advise: “Make nature a central partner in the farm business: the natural resources of the farm are the basis of genuinely sustainable agricultural production.” Decades of farming policy and support that has incentivised and driven production, intensification and in places unsustainable agriculture has, for many, broken this vital link between nature and resilient food production. The SFS has a key role in using public money to help reverse this with a fair transition to a more sustainable way of farming, and to make sure we do not shy away from doing what is hard but necessary. Acquiescing to fears of change helps no farm business.
Next steps
We will work with the decision made, in the interest of moving forward, this includes considering the new ‘tree and hedgerow planting plans’ as a first step, not a final one. Plans, especially funded by public money, are only as good as their implementation. Given these decisions made on the universal layer, the optional and collaborative layers are now more important than ever in helping farmers implement land management that will restore nature, tackle climate change and promote sustainable food production
It’s extremely important now to get clarity on:
- What ‘demonstrating progress’ looks like for those tree-planting plans
- How the governance mechanism will work to ensure implementation
- What happens if a plan isn’t implemented at all
- Will there be enough support available to advise people on best practice, especially with ongoing management; it doesn’t start and stop with just the planting
We repeatedly hear from all stakeholders involved in the shaping of the SFS that an evidence-based approach is vital – the evidence clearly shows that healthy, well-managed and connected habitats, across farms and landscapes, are the best way to fulfil our climate and nature obligations, as well as make farms more resilient to future climate challenges.
We will continue to work with Welsh Government and all stakeholders on making the SFS the best it can be. There is some exemplary work taking place across Wales and farmers need the support, advice and, importantly, reassurance of sufficient payment rates, so they can plan ahead and continue being the stewards of our land.
Scheme uptake is essential, and we hope that, now Welsh Government has delivered the flexibility requested by farmers, we now see all working together to make sure the Scheme deliver for nature, climate, farming and the public purse.

